"Putting $8,000 or $10,000 into the city coffers before I even sell one item is just a huge hurdle," Councilmember Urban Carmel said, passing along what he had heard from people trying to open businesses under Mill Valley's old rules. The Mill Valley Briefing printed the quote in August, in a block-by-block count of every street-level storefront downtown.
Those rules have since been rewritten. Two months after that count, the most famous dark storefront in town has a new restaurant serving dinner. Several more papered windows have tenants signed and are working toward opening. The empty storefronts mostly have tenants on the way.
Sixteen Dark Storefronts, Nine Already Spoken For
As of the Briefing's August 16 survey, downtown had 93 street-level storefronts. Sixteen had no open business. Nine of those sixteen already had a confirmed new tenant that had not yet opened, which left seven spaces with no tenant at all.
Those seven work out to a 7.5% vacancy rate. That is above the 6% national retail vacancy rate for the second quarter of 2026 and close to the 7.4% historical average, both figures from Cushman and Wakefield. Count all sixteen dark windows and the share rises to 17.2%, which is closer to how the street looks to someone walking it.
So a walk down Throckmorton in August looked emptier than the leases actually were. A few spaces, including 57 and 60 Throckmorton, had been empty for years even after tenants were confirmed.
El Paseo's Short Dark Spell
El Paseo shows the pattern most clearly. The courtyard complex at 17 Throckmorton dates to 1948 on the city's Historic Resources Inventory, which describes it as a set of connected buildings and alleys. The Holtum Building next door at 11–15 Throckmorton is listed separately, dated 1908. According to local histories, Edna and Henry Foster bought the property in 1938. They began renovating in 1940 with architect Augustus "Gus" Costigan and finished the courts, gardens and passageway in 1948, in an Old World style modeled on the footpaths of Spanish towns.
The restaurant inside has changed hands several times. In 2011, Eater SF covered its relaunch under Sammy Hagar and Tyler Florence as an American steakhouse, with Preston Clark as chef de cuisine and a $90 porterhouse for two. The Mill Valley Chamber of Commerce reported that Ki Yong Choi's group took over in 2019. Its Paseo: A California Bistro opened December 10, 2020, and served its last dinner on December 20, 2025.
By September 24, 2026, the Chamber was calling Lima Nikkei "the new Peruvian-Japanese restaurant in Mill Valley's historic El Paseo." The restaurant catered appetizers at the October 18 Milley Awards at the Mill Valley Community Center. The space had been dark for less than a year.
Lima Nikkei was founded by owner Edwin Sandoval. The menu runs from sushi, tiradito and ceviche to robata, katsu and cocktails. It serves dinner only: 4 to 9 p.m. Sunday through Thursday, and 4 to 10 p.m. Friday and Saturday. Reservations are online.
What Changed at City Hall in Between
El Paseo's quick turnaround coincided with a cheaper path to opening. The Briefing reported that a November ordinance dropped new parking requirements for most changes of use under 5,000 square feet. In April, the City Council approved a zoning rewrite, effective May 20. For most ground-floor businesses it replaced the old Conditional Use Permit with a faster Administrative Use Permit.
Senior Planner Daisy Allen told the Briefing the new administrative permit costs $1,954. The standard use permit fee fell from $7,339 to $5,647. Compare that with the $8,000 to $10,000 Carmel described and the change is clear. A new tenant now pays much less up front before it can open. Anyone weighing a permit should confirm the current fees and requirements with the City of Mill Valley's planning staff. This is general information, not legal or financial advice.
Miller Avenue and Throckmorton, Address by Address
The nine signed spaces from August are opening on different schedules. Here is where the downtown tenants stood in the third week of October.
| Address | Before | Now |
|---|---|---|
| 17 Throckmorton | Paseo: A California Bistro | Lima Nikkei, open for dinner |
| 12 Miller Ave | Sprout | Milkweed Kids, open since a September 12 grand opening |
| Miller Avenue | Gravity Tavern | Delphine, still listed as coming soon |
| Miller Avenue | Urban Remedy | Bootjack bakery, signed |
| 60 Throckmorton | Bank of America | Treehouse MV, under construction |
| 55 Sunnyside | Post Office | Wonderhouse, planned for this fall |
Milkweed Kids sells natural clothing, toys and gear for babies and children. The Chamber listed its grand opening for the morning of September 12.
Delphine is the next restaurant opening on the list. A release dated April 29, 2026 named Berk Kinalilar, owner of Troya, as the restaurateur behind it. His wife and business partner, Betul Kinalilar, owns the Troya in Tiburon. The release described Delphine as a coastal-Mediterranean concept and targeted a summer 2026 opening. Summer has passed. Delphine's website still says "coming soon" and promises mezes, seasonal vegetables, seafood, grilled meats and an outdoor patio. The space has been dark a while. The Marin Independent Journal reported that Gravity Tavern served its last meal in October 2025.
Bootjack bakery is signed for the former Urban Remedy storefront on Miller. Its operator and opening date have not been announced.
The old Bank of America at 60 Throckmorton is one of the spaces that has been empty for years. It is planned as Treehouse MV, a mix of retail and co-working. In July, the Briefing reported a $2.297 million tenant-improvement permit for the site. Wonderhouse, a family co-working space, is planned for the old Post Office building at 55 Sunnyside. The August report expected it to open this fall.
Down the street at 38 Miller Ave, Dorado 806 used an empty storefront for a group show, "Lesser Known Monsters," from September 18 to October 17.
The Seven Without a Name
Seven storefronts had no tenant announced in August. They are the real vacancies, and they include some of downtown's most visible corners:
- 88 Throckmorton, formerly Peet's Coffee
- 77 Throckmorton, formerly Mili
- 108 Throckmorton, formerly the Chandler Gallery
- 111 Throckmorton, formerly Two Neat
- 153 Throckmorton, formerly Oska
- 23 Sunnyside, formerly the Kim Eagles-Smith Gallery, where work had started inside
- 32 Miller Ave
The new permit rules have not filled these spaces. Jim Welte, executive director of the Mill Valley Chamber of Commerce, told the Briefing that part of what keeps some corners dark is "developers who have money to purchase, but don't yet have a vision for their space." The Briefing keeps a downtown storefront tracker and has asked readers to email when a new sign goes up in a window.
Downtown in November
The open storefronts already have a full calendar, most of it within a short walk of El Paseo:
- The Addams Family, a musical at Throckmorton Theatre, opens Friday, October 30 and runs through November 15. Tickets are listed at $30 to $48.
- First Tuesday ArtWalk is November 3, 5:30 to 7:30 p.m., according to the Chamber's calendar.
- Chamber Music Marin presents Rachel Barton-Pine in "Brahms and Friends" on November 15, 5 to 7 p.m.
- The free Noon Concert at Throckmorton Theatre, 142 Throckmorton Avenue, features the Earhart Trio on Wednesday, November 18, noon to 1 p.m.
- Marin Bluegrass Sessions, an open jam at Sweetwater Music Hall, is Sunday, November 22. Doors open at 11:30 a.m. and music runs noon to 2 p.m. It is free and no tickets are needed.
- Mentalist Jay Alexander plays Throckmorton Theatre on November 27 and 28.
Lima Nikkei opens at 4 p.m. every day, early enough for dinner before the 7 p.m. opening-night curtain of The Addams Family at Throckmorton Theatre, up the same street.
Scott Woods follows downtown Mill Valley's storefronts closely because they shape how a street feels long before they show up in any market report. If you own a home within walking distance of Throckmorton or Miller and want to talk through what these openings mean for your property, Scott Woods is glad to start that conversation.